When I set out to read John Green’s runaway bestselling YA
novel The Fault in Our Stars last
year, I fully expected to adore it. I wanted
to adore it. Star-crossed romance? Female protagonist? Teen fiction that actually
takes its audience seriously? Glowing critical reviews that included phrases
like “heartbreaking”,
“brutally
honest” and “tough,
touching valentine to the human spirit”? It sounded right up my alley, the
kind of book I’d fall in love with in a heartbeat.
For the
first few pages, it seemed promising. I enjoyed narrator Hazel Grace
Lancaster’s droll tone, her scathing indictment of the weekly support group she
attends to appease her mother; it’s like something from J.D. Salinger or Chuck
Palahnuik – wordy, clever and cynical, even malicious, but authentically so. As
it turned out, though, that was the highlight of the novel. I first felt my
spirits sink when Augustus Waters appeared on the scene and Hazel observed,
without a hint of irony, that “He was hot.” Not “handsome” or even the slightly
more-tolerable “cute”, but hot. What’s
more, the description doesn’t go any more in-depth than that, so we have to just
take for granted that Augustus is as breathtakingly attractive as Hazel claims.
This was probably supposed to be endearing, a reminder that although she’s
diagnosed with a terminal illness, Hazel is still a regular person just like you. But for me, it was
off-putting and patronizing, a grown man’s lame attempt at impersonating a
stereotypical teenage girl.
Then
came the cigarette “metaphor”, which I still can’t think about without rolling
my eyes because it makes no freaking
sense (a metaphor is a comparison; it’s basic English, dude). And
Augustus’s habit of calling Hazel “Hazel Grace”. And Hazel’s favorite book, a
made-up novel called An Imperial
Affliction that ends in mid-sentence for vague, profound reasons. And the
dialogue loaded with periodic all-caps and words like “existentially fraught
free throws” that have no business being placed in consecutive order. And the trip to Amsterdam that culminates
with Hazel and Augustus kissing in the Anne Frank house to the applause of
their fellow visitors, a moment that’s supposed to be romantic and triumphant
but really just comes off as manipulative and insensitive. And the scene where
Hazel helps vandalize the car of a girl she’s never talked to or even met
because obviously, Monica must be a heartless bitch for dumping Isaac and it
can’t possibly matter what her side of the story is. And the part when Peter
Van Houten inexplicably shows up in Hazel’s car and we’re not supposed to find
it creepy as hell because he reveals some tragic backstory that explains his
asshole behavior, except it just makes him seem more pathetic than before and I don’t even care in the first place.
All in
all, it was a colossal disappointment. There were occasional moments that I
found genuinely touching, like when Hazel cringes at the painfully insincere
condolence messages left behind for a deceased cancer patient, or Augustus’s
sweeping declaration of his love for Hazel (Titanic
and Casablanca are two of my favorite
movies ever, so I have nothing against grand romantic gestures), but those were
far outnumbered by the times I had to resist shutting the book out of
exasperation. Still, for a while, I put off writing about it. I’ve been trying
my damnedest not to be one of those narrow-minded snobs who reflexively
dismisses anything aimed at teenage girls, and it’s not like I consider myself
superior or more discerning for defying popular opinion; if anything, I envy
the novel’s fans, since there are few things as rewarding as literature that
burrows into your soul and makes you feel like a somehow wiser, fuller person.








