***SPOILER ALERT!***
Pacific Rim
Iron Man 3
One of the first topics brought
up in any conversation about gender politics in pop culture is the Bechdel
Test. You probably know what I’m referring to, but in case you’ve been living
under a rock or need a refresher, here’s
a helpful link that not only explains the test’s rules, but also evaluates
recent movies based on well they fulfill those requirements. When explaining the test’s purpose, it’s
tempting to say that it shows how “feminist” a movie or TV show is; however,
that’s not quite accurate, and such an explanation is both overly simplistic
and misleading.
Really, the Bechdel Test has very little to do with indicating what films
are women-friendly or the overall quality of the work itself, and as an arbiter
of individual movies, it’s a next-to-pointless exercise. Nowhere is there any
criteria dictating how complex or plot-essential a female character should be
in order to count, though a sometimes-included rule requiring the characters to
have a name means passing movies will have two women who aren’t just glorified
extras. Even then, they could be horribly offensive stereotypes (see: Anne
Hathaway’s shameful post-first-Oscar-nomination dud Bride Wars). In addition, its pass/fail grading system makes it
easy for people to turn the test into the be-all-end-all of feminist pop
culture criticism, potentially shutting down more in-depth conversations about how
the work actually deals with gender. Again, just because a movie passes, it
doesn’t mean that it’s feminist or a good movie, and a movie that fails isn’t
necessarily sexist or bad.
This isn’t to say that we should straight-up burn the Bechdel Test. In
fact, even almost thirty years after it was first conceived, it remains an
important and (sadly) relevant tool. Its problems arise less from the test
itself and more from people who misuse or don’t completely understand it. The
test works best when you broaden the scope and critique entertainment on an industry-wide
scale; whether one specific film does or doesn’t pass is of no consequence, but
after looking at enough movies, a trend emerges: the fails are way more
numerous than the passes. Considering how rudimentary the test is, this
knowledge is sobering, to put it mildly. ‘Cause women never have anything more
fascinating than dudes to talk about, amiright?
I think these ladies would beg to differ.




